The Nothingburger of the Buyer Representation Scandal


Well, we’re six weeks into the biggest shift in real estate history. I’m talking, of course, about the requirement across most of the country (except in New York City) for buyers to sign “buyer representation agreements” before agents will show them properties.

The Wall Street Journal was breathless about the billions of dollars that buyers were going to save, because they could go out and buy a home on their own without an agent. Agents were panicked, thinking that their buyer-representation business would dry up overnight.

chatGPT’s failed attempt #1 at a nothingburger

They were both completely wrong. What’s happened?

  • Sellers are still hiring agents, and offering commission to buyer agents
  • Buyers are happily signing buyer representation agreements
  • 99% of all deals have sellers paying the commission to buyer agents
  • Buyers are happy
  • Sellers are happy
  • The markets are functioning perfectly well
  • Extra trees are dying because of all these agreements

All of this is to say that essentially business went on as usual. I can’t say that I’m shocked, except that I thought it would take a while, maybe years, for all of this to shake out. That it was going to have to get much worse before it returned to stasis. I can’t believe where we are. But I guess that people still wanted to move forward with living.

failed version #2

Perhaps you’ve been so busy living your life that you missed this big scandal, and the months of handwringing, and the ink spilled over the corrupt, greedy brokerage industry. It turns out that buyers still need agents and sellers still need agents. Go figure! People can’t manage this crazy transaction on their own.

We knew this all along. -Scott & The HRT

Recent Blog Posts

The End of Rental Broker Commissions As You Know It. The Beginning of Even-Higher Rents.
The Sometimes Secret to Dealmaking? Waiting. (Our Deal of the Month @ 52 Riverside Drive)
(VIDEO) Don’t Take My Word For It. The NYC Housing Market is Better Than You’ve Heard.
How Much does Overcustomization Cost? (Our Deal of the Month)
A New Way To Save Real $$ on your Prewar Apartment Renovation—by Using Smart Home Systems (and Calling the Electrician)
(VIDEO) The Win-Win Window is Closing
What Happens when Your Agent Becomes an Advisor? Our Deal of the Month: 24 East 82nd
The Nothingburger of the Buyer Representation Scandal
The Non-Binary Housing Market
(VIDEO) How Lower Rates Are Already Impacting the NYC Housing Market

Archives