Are We in a NYC Housing Crisis?


While it has been about four years since the lows of the market in 2009, that time for me seems both far, far away, and still strongly memorable.

Empty open houses, few bids, few inquiries, few buyers who wanted to move forward.

The busy days of 2005-2008 seemed incredibly far away for that year.

Some Painful 2008 Memories


As 2013 moves forward- can we already nearing Memorial Day?- we’re seeing velocity in the market that makes those four quarters (Q4’08-Q3’09) seem like a blip.
Here are a few thoughts I’ll juxtapose next to the troubling image alongside:

  • Best and Final bidding on nearly every two-bedroom condominium which hits the market
  • $1500 per square foot is becoming commonplace, and $2000-2500 per square foot more so for larger units or new construction
  • Mortgage Contingencies starting to disappear for many deals
  • Bidding wars on many Upper West Side properties in general, certainly two-bedrooms and larger
  • A trickle of inventory, still down 30% year over year
  • $5mm and up property inventory down 26% year over year
  • Rents looking markedly more expensive than purchasing event at today’s pricing
  • Buyers growing increasingly hostile, aggressive, frustrated, annoyed, and depressed
Is it any wonder that I’m wondering to you whether we’re in a housing crisis in New York City?

This weekend’s NYTimes discusses the uber-luxury properties on the market right now.

Prices continue their rise because the properties still look cheap.

Not just to foreign money, but to New Yorkers as well.

Despite what could be viewed as seller greed (aka aggressive pricing), as properties continue to be snapped up it just appears to be prudent strategy.
I’ve covered in previous months all the steps buyers must take to be seriously considered- Would I want to be a buyer right now?

How cheap does New York City property look right now compared to other world markets?

Are we in a bubble again in New York?

I would argue that with rates where we are, the rent vs buy calculation (see here for the New York Times version here) still makes lots of sense.

Add in the world uncertainty of how governmental policies are affecting Europeans, South Americans and Americans alike, it is no surprise to me that hard assets (perhaps except Gold at the moment) are in hot demand.

It is almost too dynamic a market to stop and look around.

Buyers who wait often find themselves with little to consider- when everything they saw on a Sunday is gone by the following Friday.

All I will add is that I have a sales pitch for sellers.

If you’re thinking about selling, you have as

little competition for your apartment as there has been in over 15 years.

Demand hasn’t been this high even in the rollicking times of 2005-2008 in New York City, especially in Brooklyn!

I continue to work to unlock some inventory for the marketplace as I speak to prospective sellers- I expect that we’ll see some pivot point in the next 9-12 months- but it seems to continue to be pushed off a quarter at a time.

Our Brown Harris Stevens chief economist sees no short-term end to the fiscal policies of the US government, and nothing drastic changing the atmosphere of the marketplace.

So are we in a housing crisis?

Most likely yet.

Would I be a buyer in this market?

Certainly, and I have been- I just sold and bought last quarter.

Opportunities are there.

You just need the right team to make it happen.

I see 2014 as a year where we’ll see another push into new pricing territory.

The market could very well go beyond the craziness that we’re seeing now.

For now, hold onto your seats.

Recent Blog Posts

Deal of the Month: When the Third Time (or Agent) Is The Charm
(VIDEO) The Quarterly Report Is Old News
Deal of the Month: How to Know You’re Getting A Good Deal In the Moment—An Upper West Side Purchaser Story
(VIDEO) The One Thing You Need To Know About the Market (and ignore the rest)
My Experience with Fake Renters, aka Section 8 Ambulance Chasers
How Will The NAR Settlement (and its copycat lawsuits) Impact New York City’s Real Estate Market?
What The NAR Settlement Means For the Real Estate Industry
Apply To Be On The Pursuit Of Home Podcast
(VIDEO) What Are You Waiting For? The Manhattan & Brooklyn Aren’t Waiting For Spring to Bloom
The Silent Killer? Building Operation Costs. Here’s What Buildings—and NYC—Can Do About It.

Archives