551 West 21st and Cast Iron House – A Review


Let’s chat about 551 West 21st Street, a boutique new development whose sales office I visited last week.

551 West 21st Street


Full disclosure:

My firm is marketing the property, but I am not.

This just-born project, one of many in the hopper for Sir Norman Foster of Foster & Partners,

is stunning.
One of my favorites

of his creations

was the addition

atop the original Hearst Building, known as the Hearst Tower.

He and his team are moving forward on any number of projects.

Another we know about is an RFR development in the East 50’s.

And there was a pretty remarkable one at 980 Madison, which never came to pass.


I have written about 50 UN Plaza, which, in this reviewer’s humble opinion, was not nearly as successful as what’s been delivered at 551 West 21st Street, despite a good deal of similar features.

Both feature prominent, sweeping River views.

Both feature limited unit numbers.

Both feature driveways that elicit some level of drooling.

Both feature attention to exterior window design – and

huge picture windows.
But the design palette here

may be

more adventurous, exhibiting a desire, perhaps, to

embrace a contemporary-yet-throwback mentality.

These rooms are less urban and more of the oversized variety I just discussed in my “diatribe” post

on city vs. suburban.
If you look at this recent article on upcoming developments, so many boutique full-service buildings are

coming to market, each housing only

30-75 buyers.

So much opportunity to test this hypothesis.

551 Kitchens


With West Chelsea

as the

hub of this amazing construction, and with the High Line’s impact on residential living amongst galleries, we are

seeing things trading at incredible numbers.

These apartments warrant top dollar.

The above

picture belies the warmth of this kitchen, the stunning herringbone flooring in all the public rooms, the richly designed smallest details – closets, built-ins, baths, and so on.

The three-bedrooms are over 3000 square feet, so we are talking about generous proportions in all the units. Contracts were

out and signed on many of the high floor units in just a few weeks.

Perhaps I enjoy this color palette, even the champagne-colored window detail that reads aglow into the units.

Or perhaps I just

prefer the Hudson River.
Cast Iron House

Moving on

from his Shutter House in West Chelsea, Shigeru Ban has designed a stunner in Tribeca, the

Cast Iron House.

Here are

remarkable finishes and thought to

layouts, retrofitting the spaces into the old building, creating incredibly interesting duplexes.

Except

from the 2nd floor units (which, with low ceilings,

are priced at $1600-$1700 per square foot),

the units have great room ceilings of 15′ or more.

The penthouses offer dramatic transitions from inside to outside.

Further, the

amenities for as small a building as this are robust, to say the least.

Really,

the result

is

hardly

one step removed from being private residence,

for which people are willing to pay much, much more.

If

we consider that a top-tier renovation would cost $500-$1000 per square foot, purchasing a Shigeru-Ban designed property at $1600-$2300 per square foot doesn’t seem that radical.

Ban is going for something slightly more upscale than this massive loft.

Further, the ability to purchase a four-bedroom unit in the $6-8mm range in Tribeca without the Star Architect isn’t outlandish.

Now, the common charges are pretty high.

$2.40-2.80 per square foot.

That may have been a bit of a drag on pricing, but for the level of amenities, this may not be an issue right now.

In all the units, the flooring is 5″ wide plank white oak, custom Ban-designed

white laquer cabinetry, white

marble counters, Gaggenau for the entire appliance package.

Fully pre-wired for a/v, and of course the double-height ceilings.

Really, ceiling height appears to be a signature of Ban’s design in the building.

Corian continues to be a popular choice in the baths, catching on again over the last 5-7 years.

Some of the Penthouse details, beyond their $3000 per square foot price tags, include

Sliding walls by Schuco, radiant floors in the baths, a system to keep the outside out and the inside in for the sliding walls- and the massive outdoor terraces.

While the building is not going for any LEED certification, and this is not a view building, the location puts it within one block of the newest Gourmet Garage going into Tribeca at 366 Broadway.

The Tribeca buyer is less concerned with views than with finishes, space, and location.

This should be a huge success.

Recent Blog Posts

Deal of the Month: When the Third Time (or Agent) Is The Charm
(VIDEO) The Quarterly Report Is Old News
Deal of the Month: How to Know You’re Getting A Good Deal In the Moment—An Upper West Side Purchaser Story
(VIDEO) The One Thing You Need To Know About the Market (and ignore the rest)
My Experience with Fake Renters, aka Section 8 Ambulance Chasers
How Will The NAR Settlement (and its copycat lawsuits) Impact New York City’s Real Estate Market?
What The NAR Settlement Means For the Real Estate Industry
Apply To Be On The Pursuit Of Home Podcast
(VIDEO) What Are You Waiting For? The Manhattan & Brooklyn Aren’t Waiting For Spring to Bloom
The Silent Killer? Building Operation Costs. Here’s What Buildings—and NYC—Can Do About It.

Archives